5/26/2005

5/26/2005

5/26/2005

5/25/2005

7/28/2005

Results of the Women's Health Study – Vitamin E in the Primary Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease and Cancer

Perhaps you've seen the headlines…

“Aspirin, vitamin E fail to prevent cancer in women, key study finds…Neither low-dose aspirin nor vitamin E supplements prevent cancer in women, and vitamin E also does little or nothing to prevent heart disease in them, according to results of a study released yesterday.” Associated Press

“ Not so fast! Vitamin E proves no cure-all. A new study shows that a popular supplement may have no particular effect on the health of women. Dr. Judith Reichman has details…” Newsweek

“Healthy Women Don't Need Aspirin, Vitamin E

Regular Aspirin or Vitamin E Doesn't Prevent Cancer, Heart Disease” Medical News Service

But the study's results show vitamin E is beneficial and protective!

Although Vitamin E was not found to be effective for the prevention of breast, lung, or colon cancer, or death due to cancer, Vitamin E was effective for reducing cardiovascular death and heart attacks in women.

This large study included about 40,000 women who received either the vitamin E or a placebo for 10 years. Women (aged 45 years or older) receiving the vitamin E experienced a significant 24% reduction of cardiovascular death.

However for older women, those affected most by cardiovascular disease, vitamin E was more effective. Vitamin E reduced all major cardiovascular events in women over 65 years of age by 26%, due to a 34% reduction in heart attacks and a 49% reduction in cardiovascular deaths.

Indeed, the data and results found vitamin E beneficial and protective. However, the researchers were testing mainly whether “vitamin E supplementation for 10 years decreased risks of major CVD (cardiovascular disease) and cancer in a large group of healthy women”. The researchers defined major CVD as a composite (total) of several events. In the total group of women for the composite of cardiovascular events, vitamin E was not effective compared with a placebo, at the 10 year time period. Because of this finding, the researchers concluded that, “the data doe not support recommending vitamin E supplementation for cardiovascular disease or cancer prevention amoung healthy women.” And the media mostly dismissed the positive and stated that vitamin E was found ineffective as a protective measure against cardiovascular disease.

Lee and others. JAMA, 2005: (294)56-65
http://jama.ama-assn.org/

Comments

Why was this study turned into a "Man Bites Dog" study?

Is there no news value in a study that confirms earlier research that vitamin e is beneficial for cardiovascular health and disease reduction?

Why didn't the media report, "… Vitamin E reduces Cardiovascular death by 49% ins older women" or “"itamin E reduces heart attack risk in older women"?


5/25/2005

5/25/2005

Disclaimer: The statements and information upon this website have not necessarily been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. The products featured are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Consumers should always consult their own medical practitioner(s) with any medical or health concerns before starting any new diet, product or supplement.